Experience can give you answers before you ask enough questions

Knowing what usually happens can make it harder to see what happened this time

Experienced police officer listens to a woman outside a home while another woman watches from the doorway.

Most of what I call experience started out as questions. I ran into situations I hadn’t seen before, slowed down, listened, asked what happened, and tried to figure out what I was missing.

After enough years, some of those questions turn into patterns. I recognize certain problems faster now than I did early on. That’s useful. It’s also where experience can get me in trouble. The more familiar something feels, the easier it is to believe I already know the rest of the story.

I’ve seen enough arguments to recognize when one is starting to move toward a fight. I’ve reviewed enough reports to notice when something important seems to be missing. I’ve listened to enough explanations to know when one part doesn’t fit the rest of what I’m hearing.

Those instincts come from repetition, training, mistakes, correction, and seeing what happened after earlier decisions. I trust them enough to tell me where to look first. I don’t trust them enough to call them proof.

Subscribe to Field Notes

The stories and ideas I don’t want you to miss.

Two situations can look almost identical from the outside and still require different decisions. One fact can change what the law allows. A person who looks calm may be the one in danger. An explanation I’ve heard a hundred times may have been false the first ninety-nine and true the next one.

The problem starts when my first answer begins controlling every question that comes after it. I can still ask questions and listen to people while only hearing the parts that support what I already decided. I may think I’m gathering information when I’m really just building a case for my first impression.

The same thing can happen in leading people. I know people well enough to recognize familiar explanations, repeated mistakes, and recurring conflicts. That history gives me context. It doesn’t make the current situation a copy of the last one.

One of the checks I use is simple: what fact would make me change my conclusion? If I can’t answer that, I’m probably too attached to the answer I already have.

I also try to separate what I actually know from what I’m assuming. Who haven’t I heard from? What am I taking for granted? Am I treating a familiar pattern like a finished investigation? None of that means I always get unlimited time to decide. Sometimes I have to act before every fact is available. Experience helps with that too. It gives me something to work from when the picture is incomplete.

What I don’t want to confuse is urgency with certainty. I can make the best decision I can with what I know now and still be willing to correct course when new information changes the picture. I’ve been wrong enough times to know the first version of a story is often incomplete.

Experience should make me faster at recognizing what I’m looking at.

It shouldn’t make me harder to correct when I’m wrong.

SHARE
|

Subscribe to Field Notes

The stories and ideas I don’t want you to miss.

You Also Might Like

  • Humanoid robot pointing to paperwork as a supervisor reviews and signs documents across from an employee.

    When human review becomes a rubber stamp

  • Police officer sitting beside a packed box in a locker room, considering leaving the job.

    Sometimes quitting is the responsible career decision

  • Two patrol officers talking beside a marked police car after a routine call, representing police partnership and trust built during ordinary shifts.

    What End of Watch understands about partnership

  • A police officer talks with four people beside a black Chevrolet Tahoe at a crowded outdoor field party at night.

    Twenty years of experience or one year repeated twenty times?

  • Police employee reviews license plate search records while a supervisor examines an audit log.

    If one employee can abuse a police system 2,700 times, that’s not just an employee problem

  • A white humanoid robot sits on a throne flanked by robot guards while a group of people gathers below.

    They put the AI in charge before it was ready